Best Italian Restaurant in Nottingham (2026)

What they do: Pizzamisú offers a 'Slice of Naples In Nottingham', specialising in authentic Neapolitan pizzas available for order and collection or delivery. They also feature special menus for occasions like Valentine's Day.

What customers say: Customers consistently praise Pizzamisú for its authentic Neapolitan-style pizzas, describing them as 'incredible', 'fresh', 'tasty', and with 'airy crusts'. The atmosphere is noted as having 'good vibes' that transport diners back to Napoli. Service is also highlighted as lovely and very kind.

What they do: Farro's Grillhouse offers a newly refurbished, alcohol-free venue perfect for special occasions, private events, or casual dining with friends. They aim to provide delicious food, excellent value, and quick, friendly service, with options for takeaway and desserts.

What customers say: Customers praise Farro's Grillhouse as a fantastic spot for relaxed family meals, highlighting the fresh, flavorful food, especially the perfectly cooked beef. Many commend the brilliant, quick, and friendly service, along with the high quality and excellent presentation of dishes. The mocktails and desserts also receive positive mentions, though one review noted chewy steak and lamb.

What they do: Information not currently available.

What customers say: Recognised for excellence based on public review signals.

What they do: Dino operates as a wine bar and restaurant, offering lunch, evening, and dessert menus, with options for booking and vouchers.

What customers say: Customers consistently praise Dino for its delicious food, friendly and attentive staff, and fabulous atmosphere. Many highlight the good prices, especially for a city establishment, and appreciate the warm, stylish setting. Some minor feedback included cocktail presentation and a desire for small birthday gestures.

What they do: Compa Nottingham offers a menu and booking services, inviting customers to learn more about them or join their team.

What customers say: Customers describe Compa Nottingham as a brilliant, intimate, and cosy restaurant with flavourful, authentic Sicilian food. Reviewers consistently praise the high quality of the dishes, the attentive and friendly staff, and the pleasant atmosphere. Many highlight the genuine Italian taste and the freshness of ingredients.

What they do: This modern bistro offers a range of Italian dishes, including A La Carte, desserts, and drinks, with options catering to gluten-free, vegetarian, and vegan dietary requirements. They also provide collection, delivery, and gift cards.

What customers say: Customers consistently praise the fantastic food, highlighting dishes like sea bass and carbonara, and describe the service as first-class, attentive, and friendly. The restaurant is noted for its atmospheric, lovely, clean, and nicely decorated setting, making for a truly memorable dining experience.

What they do: The Pelican Club is an Italian restaurant and jazz bar specializing in rustic, traditional Umbrian dishes made with fresh local and imported Italian produce. They offer a regularly changing seasonal menu, including separate vegetarian and vegan options, alongside a fine selection of Italian wines and cocktails, complemented by live jazz performances.

What customers say: Guests rave about the fantastic live jazz music and the cosy, intimate ambience, enhanced by charming decor. The cocktails are highly rated, and the staff, including Dan and Emilia, are consistently described as friendly, attentive, and welcoming, contributing to a 'heavenly' and memorable experience.

What they do: Information not currently available.

What customers say: Customers describe the food as authentic Italian, with freshly made pasta and a small menu ensuring quality. Dishes like beef tortellini, anchovy pasta, tiramisu, and garlic and chilli prawns receive high praise. The venue offers a cosy, homely, and family feel, with generally attentive and friendly staff, though some recent reviews noted a decline in service and food quality.

What they do: Information not currently available.

What customers say: Recognised for excellence based on public review signals.

What they do: Pici offers fresh pasta made daily, pizzettes, and small plates, inspired by European and UK restaurants. They focus on simple dishes with bold flavours and quality ingredients, paired with low-intervention wines, great beers, and classic spritzes, providing a relaxed and lively dining experience in Hockley.

What customers say: Diners praise Pici for its amazing cocktails, lovely reception, and helpful staff. The pasta dishes, such as Pici Cacio e Pepe and mutton ragu, are consistently described as perfect and high quality. The restaurant is noted for its cool, relaxed vibe, great atmosphere, and good energy, making for a delightful dining experience.

What they do: Information not currently available.

What customers say: Customers consistently praise the excellent, Italian-style pizza for its amazing flavours, fresh preparation, and outstanding crust. Staff are described as very pleasant, friendly, and welcoming. While some note the food is tremendous, there were mentions of service being a little slow and pricing being quite expensive. The option to bring your own alcohol for a 10% charge is appreciated, though the entrance was noted as not wheelchair accessible.

What they do: Established in September 2021, Bar Gigi is an independent modern Italian restaurant located above the Gigi Bottega boutique in Nottingham. It offers a refined yet relaxed dining experience that celebrates simplicity, seasonality, and exceptional quality, reflecting the cosmopolitan spirit of Milanese dining.

What customers say: Customers rave about the incredible and delicious food, with specific praise for dishes like scallops and gnocchi being 'out of this world.' The staff are consistently described as friendly, welcoming, attentive, and helpful, with the owner Angelo receiving special mention. The restaurant's setting in a 'stunning' and 'beautiful and historic building' also contributes to a fantastic experience.

What they do: Information not currently available.

What customers say: Navarra is praised for its 'fantastic' Italian deli shop and restaurant, run by 'Italian family owners.' Customers commend the 'great quality' food, 'fabulous fillet steaks,' and 'very generous portions' in the restaurant, alongside 'exceptional service.' The deli is noted for its helpful service and good prices on wine, though one customer mentioned 'shrivelled up and dry grapes' from outside.

What they do: Canotto Pizza is described as a Nottingham favourite offering authentic Italian pies at great prices, including a variety of pizzas, desserts, and drinks.

What customers say: Customers frequently praise the pizzas for being loaded with toppings, fantastic, and offering great value for money, with quick and friendly service. While some note a shift from Neapolitan style to a 'street food shawarma style take out' or 'kebab pizza place', they still recommend it, highlighting delicious chicken shawarma and light, fresh pizza dough.

What they do: Information not currently available.

What customers say: This 'lovely little place' is celebrated for serving authentic Italian food with a warm welcome and excellent service, often highlighting passionate staff like John and attentive Anya. Customers consistently praise the beautiful, cosy atmosphere, great menu, good quality food, and impressive wine list, making it a highly recommended 'hidden gem'.

What they do: Information not currently available.

What customers say: Customers frequently praise the pizza and calzone for their perfect, light dough, rich condiments, and super taste, often highlighting them as high-quality products for an honest price. While many find the food delicious and great value, one significant review expressed shock at a 'half-meter pizza' deal consisting of only 'six tiny, limp slices', deeming the description highly misleading.

What they do: Information not currently available.

What customers say: Customers generally praise the fresh pasta, especially when swirled on cheese, and the delicious tiramisu, often described as nutty, soft, and rich. Many highlight the friendly staff, good value, and generous portions. Some experiences mention minor issues like cold sides or pasta lacking flavor, but overall sentiment is positive, with staff often resolving issues proactively, for example, by offering replacement items or a tiramisu on the house.