Best Italian Restaurant in New York (2026)

What they do: Information not currently available.

What customers say: Customers describe the food as incredible, with unusually high-quality cheese, seafood, and pasta, particularly praising the black spaghetti with crab meat. The staff, including specific mentions of Eddy and Juancito, are noted for being friendly, attentive, and offering excellent recommendations. The atmosphere is consistently described as beautiful, intimate, and cozy. However, some customers express dissatisfaction with undisclosed surcharges for credit card payments and still water.

What they do: Information not currently available.

What customers say: Customers consistently describe the service as amazing, with staff being incredibly kind, helpful, and knowledgeable about the extensive menu and specials. The food is frequently lauded as phenomenal, delicious, and fresh, with specific praise for dishes like tagliarini with acqua di pomodoro and oxtail parpadelle. The restaurant offers an upscale, special-occasion setting with beautiful and modern decor.

What they do: Information not currently available.

What customers say: Antonio's Trattoria is described as a cozy spot known for its brick-oven thin-crust pies and homestyle Italian dishes. Customers rave about the fantastic experience, highlighting delicious fresh bread, house-made pasta, and exceptional dishes like sausage rotini rugantini and chicken parm pizza. The staff are consistently praised as incredibly friendly and attentive, contributing to a warm and magical atmosphere.

What they do: Il Miglio operates as a Brick Oven Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant, offering a menu of Italian dishes and catering services. They also provide gift cards and have an online presence through social media.

What customers say: Recognised for excellence based on public review signals. Customers consistently praise the food as 'absolutely delicious', fresh, and flavorful, with 'INSANELY fast' delivery. Reviews highlight exceptional service, welcoming owners, and a cozy, clean restaurant with a great atmosphere. Popular dishes include brick oven pizza (Pesto, vodka sauce, Cajun) and pasta.

What they do: Information not currently available.

What customers say: Enzo's of Arthur Avenue is a cozy, unpretentious neighborhood restaurant serving classic red-sauce Italian fare. Customers describe an unforgettable experience with a warm, intimate 'Little Italy' vibe and professional, top-tier customer service. Reviews consistently praise the very good and fresh food, highlighting amazing pizza, 'hands down the best' cannoli, delicious pesto pasta, chicken parm, and perfectly cooked Branzino.

What they do: Information not currently available.

What customers say: Customers consistently praise the light, airy, and substantive pizza made in a brick oven by owners genuinely from Italy. Other dishes are described as perfection, with an excellent wine selection and exceptional service. Many highlight the wonderful brunch, delicious daily specials, and happy hour, making it a great spot for both families and date nights.

What they do: Puglia is a family-owned and operated Italian restaurant, established in 1919, offering traditional Italian delicacies like Capuzzello, Tripe, and Pasta E Fagioli, alongside a menu of antipasto, calamari, baked clams, and mussels marinara. They also provide party entertainment and catering services.

What customers say: Customers describe Puglia as a fantastic restaurant with amazing food and staff, highlighting the fun ambiance with live dancing and singing around 7 pm nightly. Many consider it a 'must go' destination, praising the excellent entertainment and the owner, Joey, who treats regulars like family. The big portions of Italian basics are served in a throwback space with murals and memorabilia.

What they do: Information not currently available.

What customers say: La Voglia NYC is highly praised for its beautiful and well-mannered staff, relaxing atmosphere, and great food, including lamb chops, prosciutto pizza, mixed seafood pasta, and truffle ravioli. Customers also enjoy the impeccable dessert menu, relaxing music, classy dining, and engaging service. The cocktails are noted as excellent, and the restaurant is suitable for various occasions, from date nights to large group gatherings.

What they do: Information not currently available.

What customers say: Porto Salvo is described as a cozy spot resembling an old port tavern, offering Italian fare, local draft beers, and outdoor seating. Customers consistently highlight the super amicable, attentive, and happy staff, along with impressive and flavorful food, including light and crunchy pizzas. Many rave about the 'best spritz in town' and appreciate the welcoming, trendy atmosphere, though some found the mojitos less appealing.

What they do: Trattoria 35 offers an all-day dine-in menu, lunch menu, and extensive catering services, including private event packages and off-site catering. They also provide design and decor services, including holiday decor packages, for pharmaceutical and corporate events.

What customers say: Customers praise Trattoria 35 for its consistently good quality food, including delicious wood-fired pizzas and traditional Italian cuisine like mozzarella corozza, seafood linguine, and basil pasta. The intimate restaurant has a great vibe and warm atmosphere, with attentive servers and kind, helpful management. The owner, Billy, is noted for being funny and hospitable.

What they do: Information not currently available.

What customers say: Customers consistently praise the awesome appetizers, drinks, and main courses, highlighting the consistency in food and customer service over years. Many describe the atmosphere as relaxing, luxury, and perfect for various occasions, though one noted the lighting was 'a little too bright'. Special touches like complimentary drinks and making moments extra special are frequently mentioned.

What they do: Information not currently available.

What customers say: Customers appreciate Mario's for its 'old school' charm and exceptional, attentive service, which many describe as a rare find. The food, particularly Neapolitan-Italian red-sauce fare, receives high praise for its authenticity, with dishes like manicotti and lasagna being favorites. While some noted a need for more seasoning or occasional freshness issues, the overall sentiment highlights a warm, family-style atmosphere that makes customers feel welcomed and well-served.

What they do: VITE vinosteria is an authentic Italian fare and wine bar that prides itself on preparing food from scratch daily. They offer a diverse menu for dinner, brunch, and dessert, alongside catering and delivery services.

What customers say: Customers consistently describe VITE vinosteria as a 'true gem' offering a 'gastronomic extravaganza' with dishes prepared from the finest, freshest ingredients. Reviewers frequently praise the delicious specials, flavorful libations, and the friendly, attentive staff who make guests feel appreciated. The rustic-chic, cozy atmosphere is also a highlight, perfect for dates or family dinners.

What they do: Donna Margherita is a small Italian trattoria and wine bar offering traditional Italian comfort food with modern touches for lunch and dinner. Led by Chef Salvatore Lima, they serve a variety of pastas, entrees like Chicken Parmigiana and Grilled Mediterranean Branzino, and emphasize using only fresh ingredients.

What customers say: Customers consistently praise Donna Margherita for its exquisite food and excellent, warm, and attentive service, often mentioning staff by name. Dishes like linguine & clams, spicy rigatoni, and their pizza are frequently highlighted as perfect and authentic, with some calling the pizza 'some of the best in NY'. The atmosphere is described as intimate, cozy, and personalized, creating a truly exceptional Italian dining experience.

What they do: Information not currently available.

What customers say: Sotto la Luna is recognized as a nice quaint neighborhood Italian spot in Astoria, praised for its delicious gnocchi, pasta, and seafood, along with great drinks and attentive staff. Customers appreciate the crispy fried calamari and the variety on the pasta menu, noting the cozy vibe. While the cacio e pepe table-side plating is a highlight, some minor feedback mentioned pasta temperature or texture.

What they do: Riviera Ristorante offers an authentic mix of southern and northern Italian cuisine. Nestled in Whitestone, Queens, they aim to provide a great night out with friendly staff treating guests like family.

What customers say: This warm, casual venue is praised for its tasty Italian food, generous portions, and reasonable prices. Customers frequently highlight the excellent, caring, and friendly family atmosphere, though one review noted some dishes lacked flavor.

What they do: Vesta Trattoria & Wine Bar is a neighborhood trattoria and wine bar inspired by Italy, the local green market, and a commitment to a menu without boundaries. They offer lunch, dinner, and brunch services.

What customers say: This neighborhood spot, serving pizza and Italian comfort food with a sustainable, seasonal bent, receives five-star reviews for its fantastic pre-fixe menus and delicious dishes like pumpkin pasta and baby Jesus cake. Customers appreciate the amazing wine selection, cozy ambiance, and knowledgeable, attentive staff.

What they do: Information not currently available.

What customers say: Recognised for excellence based on public review signals.

What they do: Information not currently available.

What customers say: This casual space, offering brick-oven pizzas, pasta, and other Italian eats with a full bar and patio seating, is described as an 'absolute neighborhood gem' in Astoria. Customers rave about the 'outstanding' homemade pastas, generous portions, and flavors that 'taste like they come straight from Italy,' all within a warm, welcoming atmosphere with friendly staff.

What they do: Information not currently available.

What customers say: Customers highly recommend Da Franco & Tony Ristorante for its delicious Italian-American fare, with specific praise for homemade lasagna, seafood risotto, and tender chicken & veal parmigiana. The restaurant offers a cozy, neighborhood-joint atmosphere with spectacular, welcoming service where staff often know their clients personally.